Fresh Oysters

Up to -36%
LiveNOAA FishWatch

Damariscotta, Maine or Blue Point, Connecticut
Both Varieties Farm-Raised
Live, Shell-On Oysters
12 Oysters per Pack
Shucking Required
Species: Eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica)

Regular price $32.99 Sale price $49.99
Select Your Oysters!

Fresh Maine & Connecticut Oysters — 12 Count

Choose Damariscotta oysters from Maine or Blue Point oysters from Connecticut. Each variety is supplied live, in the shell, in a 12-count pack that requires shucking.

Choose Your Oyster Variety

  • Damariscotta, Maine: Farm-raised oysters from the Damariscotta estuary, with a balance of briny and sweet flavor.
  • Blue Point, Connecticut: Farm-raised oysters from Long Island Sound, with a briny flavor and firm texture.

Sustainably Farmed Maine Oysters

Our Damariscotta oysters are sustainably farmed. During grow-out, oysters feed by filtering the surrounding water rather than requiring added feed. Learn about Our Sustainability Standards.

Our oysters arrive unopened and require shucking. Add an oyster shucker and protective gloves if needed. Follow the product’s handling and preparation instructions.

WARNING: Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including lead which is known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food.

Both oyster varieties are farm-raised. Damariscotta oysters are grown in Maine’s Damariscotta estuary, and Blue Point oysters are grown on farms in Long Island Sound, Connecticut. Both varieties are supplied live in 12-count packs. Our Damariscotta oysters are sustainably farmed; oyster grow-out requires no added feed because oysters filter their food from the surrounding water.

What’s the Serving Size for Our Oysters?

All of our oyster collection is sold in 12 ct. per order, which is our recommended serving size per person. These sweet and briny oysters pair wonderfully with a glass of white wine or as part of a complete seafood feast with a main entrée or appetizers. Serve them before indulging in freshly cooked live Maine lobster, or add crab cakes or bacon-wrapped sea scallops to your order for a tapas-style meal.

Nutritional Benefits of Oysters

Seafood is widely regarded by medical experts and dieticians to be healthy and provide nutritional benefits not found in other meat sources. The nutritional benefits of oysters are well-documented.

Oysters are a low-calorie meat source with just 50 calories per 6 oysters while providing 6 grams of protein compared to just 1 gram of fat.

Please be Aware: Consuming raw or undercooked shellfish may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Maine Lobster Now offers next-day delivery for orders placed Monday through Friday by 8AM ET, with delivery available Tuesday through Saturday. Saturday deliveries may require an additional fee and are subject to availability. Orders are shipped with dry ice or gel packs to ensure freshness. Shipping may be affected by holidays or weather conditions. Customers are encouraged to inspect their package upon arrival and report any issues immediately with photos. For more details, refer to their shipping policy.

View our shipping policy

Simple Instructions for Storing.

At Maine Lobster Now our oysters come fresh and are never frozen. It is recommended to leave oysters under refrigeration at all times until ready to eat. For the best flavor, we recommend eating your oysters within 48 hours of delivery.

How to Eat Oysters

No Matter your oyster selection, our oysters come fresh and ready eat inside the shell. Be sure to add an oyster shucker to your purchase if you don’t have one at home.
When ready to eat your oysters:

1.) Remove from container and scrub with a hard-bristle brush to remove any built-up dirt and debris.
Submerge clean oysters in very cold water.

2.) On a cutting board (or any solid surface), wrap oyster flat-side-up in a kitchen towel and hold with non-dominant hand.

3.) Find hinge near the pointed end of the oyster and slip your shucker into the fissure. Wiggle the shucker blade in then twist to pry shell up.

4.) Separate the oyster from its shell by running knife around the top shell. It should separate with the oyster intact.

5.) Run blade under oyster to loosen and free it from the muscle and bottom half of shell.

6.) Repeat and Enjoy!!

Please be Aware: Consuming raw or undercooked shellfish may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Learn How To Shuck Oysters At Home!

Shucking oysters is easy! Don't let shucking them get you down. This is a very simple process, and with the right tools you can effortlessly enjoy the freshest oysters shipped to your home.

  • 5 stars: 121 (72%)
  • 4 stars: 21 (13%)
  • 3 stars: 14 (8%)
  • 2 stars: 2 (1%)
  • 1 star: 10 (6%)
A
Anna P. (Wasilla, AK)
So fresh and delicious! Ordering and shipping went smoothly

So fresh and delicious! Ordering and shipping went smoothly. We will be ordering more for sure.

R
Robert B. (Fayetteville, AR)
Delicious Anniversary gift

Wife and I treated ourselves to a couple dozen for our 25th. They were perfect! Arrived right in time, fresh and cold- a cooler full of love from Maine.
The Damariscottas shucked really easily, but the shells were a little brittle so I had to be careful with small fragments. Flavor was amazing- a little sweetness with that briny liquor.

Dear Robert,

Thank you for your kind review and for choosing our Fresh Maine Oysters for your special 25th anniversary! We are so happy to hear that they arrived on time and were enjoyed by you and your wife. Please accept our apologies for the brittle shells, but we are thrilled that the flavor was still amazing. Wishing you many more happy years together.

Best,
Customer Service Team

B
BillG (Saint Johnsbury, VT)
Delicious!

Enjoyed these fresh oysters very much!

J
John L. (San Diego, CA)
Oyster night didn’t disappoint — well, mostly!

A few arrived a bit dry from shipping (2-3 tops), but nothing worth sending back or complaining about.

The Damariscotta, Maine oysters? Absolutely delightful, the perfect balance of brininess and delicate sweetness that dances on the palate. A true standout.

To elevate the experience, I made four mignonette sauces:

Red Wine + Red Onions + Serrano – Deep. Spicy. Unforgettable.
White Wine + Shallots – Classic elegance with a crisp twist.
Red Wine + Shallots – Rich and refined flavor.
White Wine + Red Onions + Serrano – Bright, tangy, with just the right kick.

Would 100% do it again (maybe with a few more Damariscottas).

S
Steven E. (Las Vegas, NV)
Simply amazing

I have to say I had my doubts having live Oysters flown in from across the country but the quality of what was received was unmatched. The oysters were fresh and delicious and stayed that way the entire time until they were finished. Ive already been instructed by the wife to order these again!

C
Christina H. (Chandler, AZ)
AMAZING!!!!

This is the second time we have ordered from Maine Lobster Now and we will continue!!! The shipping costs are incredible, FREE if you order a certain amount! We vacationed in Maine late last year and am receiving email ads for y'all and we are thrilled!! I usually HATE email ads!! Your pricing and shipping are out of this world, but the quality of your products is EXCEPTIONAL!! Thank You are keep sending us more info!!!

J
Joseph R.
Fresh, quick, and large

These were the best oysters our family has had to date. They were delivered well packaged, fresh, and were much larger than we anticipated compared to what you normally receive at a restaurant. Their videos showed how easy they were to prepare and we steamed them in a large pot/strainer that we have on our backyard firepit. They are priced on the high side but being in Wisconsin, there is no other competitor who stocks oysters this large and fresh. We will purchase (and have) purchased more since then and in the future.

L
Lisa E.
Wonderful!

I have been there and bought them straight from the farm and these were just as good. I wish they were larger!

M
Michael M. (Bradenton, FL)
Overall we were happy with everything we received with some exceptions

Overall we were happy with everything we received with some exceptions. I opened the box immediately upon delivery and was met with a fowl odor. I feared it might be dead lobsters but could find no evidence of dead or rotting items. In the end, I determined that the odor was caused by the included seaweed. Remarkable! I also noticed that the frozen scallops were all half thawed. I immediately transferred them to the freezer and have not touched them since. The 2 lobsters were alive and kicking so we decided to take no chances and proceeded to boil them that evening. They were exceptionally delicious as were the oysters which I made Oysters Rockefeller out of. They were absolutely delicious. The snow crab claws were very good and we had those with the cocktail sauce I had ordered. The cocktail sauce was good but nothing to rave about. All in all we were satisfied enough to not complain to them.

Hi there, thanks for sharing your detailed feedback. We’re glad you enjoyed the lobsters, oysters, and snow crab, but we’re sorry about the odor and the partially thawed scallops. We’ll share your comments with our team and would welcome the chance to help if you have any concerns about the scallops’ condition.

L
Leslie T. (Chicago, IL)
The best

The best

M
Mary R. (Aurora, CO)
FRESH AND DELICIOUS

FRESH AND DELICIOUS

D
David H. (Stockton, CA)
Everything went like clockwork

Everything went like clockwork. The cold packs were frozen solid when they arrived. We got some to try oysters for the first time. It was comforting knowing that we were dealing with such an excellent seafood provider.

T
Tina D. (Elkton, MD)
Fresh

Fresh

A
Anonymous (Philadelphia, PA)
excellent

excellent

B
Beth S. (Morton Grove, IL)
Surprised someone in Colorado with oysters for

Surprised someone in Colorado with oysters for bday- perfect!!!

T
Terri R. (Bear, DE)
The tiniest oysters I have ever seen

The tiniest oysters I have ever seen. What a rip-off. So tiny, you should have thrown them back when harvesting. I will never purchase again.

Hi Terri, we're sorry to hear you were disappointed with the size of the oysters. We appreciate your feedback and will pass it along to our team. Thank you for giving us a try.

C
Charles R. (Newark, OH)
delicious and will order again

delicious and will order again.;.....

E
Elaine G. (Milton, MA)
Delicious

As always, the seafood was great! Fresh and delicious.

A
Anonymous (Ocilla, GA)
very small but very

very small but very good

P
Philip R. (Concord, CA)
Delicious

Couldn't be better

A
Anonymous (San Diego, CA)
Raw fresh oysters

All in tack and very good

D
Douglas I. (Audubon, IA)
Delicious

Delicious

C
Chris C. (Hohenwald, TN)
Not bad

Not bad

C
Chris C. (Hohenwald, TN)
Several smaller than 3

Several smaller than 3 inches

M
Mary A.M. (Menomonee Falls, WI)
Oysters

The oysters were great we will order again Thank you